Background image showing abstract movement Motivait Logo

The Blueprint to Advocacy:

Turning Loyalty into Advocacy for Brand Success

A Harvard study spanning 85-years recently revealed a simple yet powerful truth: people with strong personal relationships are not only happier but are also healthier and live longer than those who do not foster meaningful connections. Having strong relationships has been proven to reduce stress, provide emotional support and increase feelings of happiness and belonging, all crucial to promoting good health and longevity.
We want to ask, is it possible that this same principle could apply to brands and their relationships with their customers?
Harvard's study suggests that humans respond best to intrinsic motivations. In other words, doing things because they bring satisfaction, meaning or enjoyment, rather than for external rewards. So for brands seeking good commercial health and longevity, the secret may lie in building strong, meaningful customer relationships.

After all, today's customers have evolved. They are no longer just buying products or services, they're weighing up personal values, social perceptions and long-term impact before making decisions. Cutting through the noise and getting their attention is just the beginning. The real opportunity for brands lies in aligning with their customers' values and purpose, fostering loyalty, creating emotional resonance and inspiring advocacy that can fuel sustainable growth.
But is building loyalty and brand advocacy still possible?

And if it is, how can we cultivate the kind of Loyalty and Engagement that sparks true advocacy and active participation?
In this report, we explore the steps that nurture customer relationships beyond the transactional to cultivate deeper engagement, nurturing connections from awareness into advocacy and creating authentic, passionate brand champions along the way.

content

Introduction

Is Loyalty Still Relevant?

The Importance and Development of Brand Advocacy

From Awareness  to  Advocacy:

Environments, Experiences, Emotions and Engagement

The Journey from Awareness to Advocacy

Awareness:

Making First Impressions that Last

01.

Consideration:

Convince, Intrigue and Excite

02.

Enrolment:

Turning Interest into Commitment

03.

Participation:

Encouraging Active Engagement

04.

Retention:

Keeping the Spark Alive

05.

Advocacy:

The Difference between a Loyal Customer and a Brand Ambassador

06.

Conclusion

Building Emotional Connection:

The Key to Brand Advocacy

Creating a Sustainable Customer Engagement Strategy

Is loyalty still relevant?

In an age of endless choices, social influence and shifting consumer values, even the simplest purchase can feel complex.

So let's begin by asking the big question first: Given all the factors influencing and distracting today's customers.

can loyalty and advocacy really play a role in supporting brand success?

In short: Yes! While factors such as price sensitivity cannot be ignored during times of economic pressure, Customer Loyalty nevertheless remains incredibly relevant and powerful, arguably even more so.

People want to feel good about their purchases and that desire becomes even more pronounced when they are carefully managing their spending. The emotional impact of feeling not just satisfied but recognised and rewarded for choosing a particular brand is especially impactful when every penny counts.

80

of consumers, in the UK, participate in loyalty or reward programmes, with many believing these schemes save them money. (Mintel)

68

of European consumers express a willingness to pay more to buy from brands they are loyal to. (European Loyalty Association)

If feeling rewarded benefits the customer, what benefits does fostering loyalty bring to brands?

Two creative professionals collaborating on a mood board

The Importance
and Development
of Brand Advocacy

The ultimate goal for any brand is to turn customers into passionate advocates. For brands looking to thrive and not simply survive, the focus needs to shift to forging the type of meaningful connections that enthuse, excite and engage. Converting first-time. buyers into lifelong advocates.

Brand advocacy goes beyond loyalty. It's about authentic, voluntary support from customers, employees and influencers who genuinely believe in a brand's proposition and consistently share their positive experiences. Advocates don't just buy, they promote, influence and help build lasting trust.

At a time of fast changing, competitive landscapes and very short product lifecycles, it is too risky for a brand to depend on having the best product or the best price point to bring them guaranteed success. Building resilience into brand attraction will help withstanding the ebbs and flows of a crowded market or easily distracted audiences. That resilience can be developed by having a strong proposition that consistently delivers and reinforces positive beliefs and perceptions, through great experiences for the customer. Which is essentially the starting point for initiating advocacy.

It might sound simple, but how can you actually make this theory a reality?

Creating brand advocates starts with building authentic, meaningful connections, starting with "the individual". Every interaction, whether an online purchase, a social media exchange or an in-store visit, is an opportunity to strengthen the relationship between the brand and a customer.

These touchpoints shape the overall customer experience and while it may take hundreds of positive interactions to create an advocate, a single negative experience can drive a customer away. That's why meaningful engagement must be seen as an ongoing journey, not just a one-time effort.

Many brands mistakenly assume that simply offering a "loyalty programme" or a one-time discount is enough to foster advocacy. True engagement requires more than transactional incentives. In fact, TLC reports that 77% of loyalty programmes fail because they focus solely on rewards rather than building deeper, emotional connections.

To inspire true advocacy, brands must go beyond points and perks. They need to create experiences that consistently reinforce trust, add value and make customers feel genuinely connected to the brand.

Star
75%
would quit!
Close
75%

of people say they would stop participating in a loyalty programme after a negative experience or if their expectations weren't fulfilled. (KPMG)

From Awareness to Advocacy:

Environments, Experiences, Emotions and Engagement

Arrow pointing to next section

Turning awareness into advocacy is a nuanced and delicate process shaped by three key factors:

environments, experiences and emotions.

Understanding how these elements influence customer interactions is essential for building deep, lasting engagement.

Turning awareness into advocacy is a nuanced and delicate process shaped by three key factors:

environments, experiences and emotions.

Understanding how these elements influence customer interactions is essential for building deep, lasting engagement.

The Environments:

Where and how do customers interact with your brand?

Are your physical and digital spaces accesible, inviting and intuitive?

A well-designed environment removes friction and fosters a seamless experience.

The Experiences:

What experiences are you providing within those environments?

Do they align with your brand's values and messaging, or is there dissonance?

Are these experiences memorable in a positive way?

Every touchpoint should reinforce trust and engagement.

The Emotions:

What emotions or feelings do these environments and experiences evoke?

Are they building excitement, trust and satisfaction, or causing frustration and disengagement?

Strong emotional connections turn customers into loyal advocates.

Brands that start with the desired emotional outcome in mind can design interactions that truly resonate and that will nudge customers towards brand advocacy. But at the heart of this process is the customer. Every decision should revolve around their needs, preferences and expectations, as they are the foundation of what is trying to be built.

Customer Engagement strategies, such as loyalty programmes, must go beyond the purely transactional to sustain customer interest in the long term. When brands use data-driven personalisation to recognise and reward customers meaningfully, they reinforce trust and strengthen the bond. Customers should feel valued, understood and confident that their data is being used to enhance their experience, not just to drive sales.

Menu
Close
The Importance and Development of Brand Advocacy
From Awareness to Advocacy:
Environments, Experiences, Emotions and Engagement
01.
Awareness:
Making First Impressions that Last
02.
Consideration:
Convince, Intrigue and Excite
03.
Enrolment:
Turning Interest into Commitment
04.
Participation:
Fostering Active Involvement
05.
Retention:
Keeping the Spark Alive
06.
Advocacy:
The Difference between a Loyal Customer and a Brand Ambassador
Building Emotional Connection
Creating a sustainable Customer Engagement Strategy